No Longer a Slave but a Brother

June 22, 2025
ScripturePhilemon 10–16
PreacherSteve Hall
In this sermon 9 parts

In this week’s message from Philemon 10-16, we see how Christ changed who Onesimus was. The runaway slave became a new creature and a child of God, no longer useless but precious, and God’s providence turned a broken past into reconciliation. Our worth is not what others think or what we’ve done, but what Christ has done for us.

Introduction

I’m very happy to see all of you this morning that are here. We are precious and few here today, but you do encourage my heart.

If you would turn with me once again to the book of Philemon, the little letter of the Apostle Paul to Philemon. You find that between Titus and Hebrews. After we practice this a few weeks, we’ll all know exactly where Philemon is. And this morning, I’m going to be looking in particular at verses 10 through 16.

The Story So Far

And let me just rehearse for you what’s going on in the book of Philemon, in case you need that review. Philemon is writing this letter from his cell in Rome, and he is sending it back with a man by the name of Onesimus. Onesimus was a slave who had run away, probably defrauded in some way, and run away from Philemon and ended up in Rome.

Somehow in that encounter with Rome, because of the providence of God, he meets the Apostle Paul. Paul leads Onesimus to the Lord. Onesimus becomes like a son to the Apostle Paul as Paul disciples him, encourages him, and then it becomes very clear and necessary that Onesimus needs to return back to Philemon.

Philemon is a Christian, a leader in the church at Colossae. He’s a wealthy person, and the whole church at Colossae meets in his home. And so that’s who Paul knows, Philemon. He writes this personal letter to Philemon, encouraging Philemon to take back this man, Onesimus, and to forgive him.

And last week, we looked at the verses 8 and 9, which says, basically, to paraphrase them, Paul is saying, even though as an apostle I have the right to command you, I’m going to appeal to you based on the fact that you are a loving person, based on your reputation to love. You know, the name Philemon is based on the Greek word phileo, which means love.

And Paul is saying, you have a reputation for living up to your name. And I expect you to continue to do that as I send this man, Onesimus, back to you, to voluntarily, willingly, not being commanded, to do the right thing with this man, Onesimus. So, given that, let’s begin reading in verse 10.

The TextPhilemon 10–16

I appeal to you for my child Onesimus, whom I have begotten in my imprisonment, who formerly was useless to you, but now is useful both to you and to me. I have sent him back to you in person, that is, sending my very heart, whom I wish to keep with me, so that on your behalf he might minister to me in my imprisonment for the gospel; but without your consent I did not want to do anything, so that your goodness would not be, in effect, by compulsion but of your own free will. For perhaps he was for this reason separated from you for a while, that you would receive him back forever, no longer as a slave, but more than a slave, a beloved brother, especially to me, but how much more to you, both in the flesh and in the Lord.

Let’s ask God to bless his holy word to our heart. This is his holy inspired word.

Father, we are so thankful that you have included this precious book in your scriptures to us. We thank you for the preservation of this letter to Philemon. We thank you about the amazing, wonderful truths, so many truths, are taught to us in this little tiny book.

We pray, Father, that as we saturate our heart with this passage this morning, that you would teach us truth, that you would grow us in our understanding of what you have for us in Christ Jesus and the precious relationship that we have with you. Help us to see that, Father. Help us to see ourselves rightly. We ask this in Jesus’ name. Amen.

The Looking Glass Self

Back when I started going to college, I decided to major in criminal justice. And I was particularly, before I knew anything about it, interested in the criminology classes, because I thought criminology would be all about how you catch criminals. But it isn’t, not at all. It’s just a branch of sociology.

So as part of my education, I took lots of sociology classes, and I don’t particularly recommend sociology classes. But one thing that it does, it does teach you how the people who carry a lot of influence in this world think about things. And they are guided very much by that.

But I was thinking about that because there was one of the early fathers of modern sociology, was a man by the name of Charles Horton Cooley. And he is known, most remembered, because of an idea that he had about how we perceive ourselves. And it’s called, in sociology, the looking glass self.

And just to summarize that for us, what he believes is true, and it is true to a great degree for a lot of people, is that you form your self-image, how you actually think about yourself, you form that based on what people reflect to you. You see your reflection in other people’s expression. If they treat you like an idiot, you begin to think of yourself as an idiot.

But if you are in your social circles, if you’re treated, however they treat you, that’s sort of the way that you think. The way your brothers and sisters treat you is a great deal of the way that you tend to think about yourself. That’s called the looking glass self. So much of our identity is shaped by what others reflect back to us, or we think about our own actions and our own past.

You know, we think about ourselves, men in particular, probably most people, but especially I know it’s true of men, tend to think of themselves based on their career choices. Who are you? Well, first of all, I’m a fireman, or I’m an engineer, or I’m a computer jockey, or whatever those things that kind of defines, gives them a niche. This is what occupies their time, their thought, and they think of themselves in that role.

All of us, to some degree, can define ourselves by something that we’ve done in the past, either an achievement we take some pride in, or even more often some failure that we can’t forget. And so we’re defined by these things. When we begin to think about who we really are, we think about ourselves in light of those things, those things that took place in our past. And so that shapes our understanding of ourselves.

Onesimus in the Looking Glass

Well, we meet a man in the book of Philemon who was trapped in that looking glass self. If you were asked to ask Onesimus, you know, what do you think of yourselves, when Paul first meets him? Well, he’s going to think of himself probably a lot in those kinds of terms. He’s going to think about the way that other people think of him.

He’s a slave, a bit of property. He’s a runaway slave. He’s probably a thief or he’s a failure, either one or the other. He doesn’t think of himself as being worthwhile. He is a liability. He’s a worthless person.

People treat him and have treated him. In his state as a runaway slave, his life was considered less than nothing in Rome. If he were caught as a runaway slave, the penalty of the law was to be put him to death because he is worthless.

How do you think he thought of himself as he’s running? He’s a man who, if there was ever a person trapped in the looking glass self, in that looking glass, Onesimus is trapped in that looking glass.

But few stories in the Bible illustrate more profoundly for us the transformative hope that we can find in the power of the gospel. The story of Onesimus teaches us that coming to Christ fundamentally changes who we are. It changes who we actually are. It changes our eternal value. It changes how we relate to God. It changes how we relate to the people of God.

When we come to Christ, all these things change in us. Our relationships change. Coming to Jesus Christ is more than changing our destiny eternally. Coming to Christ is about changing our very nature.

A New Creature Born Into God’s Family

So let me read again verse 10. And in verse 10, I think we’re going to see that coming to Christ fundamentally transforms our identity, making us a new creature born into God’s family. So verse 10:

I appeal to you for my child Onesimus, whom I have begotten in my imprisonment.

Born Again

Now the word that I want to call your attention to is this language of new birth that Paul uses when he talks about him being begotten in his imprisonment. That reminds you of something, doesn’t it? It reminds you of the way that the Lord Jesus himself talked about salvation. Jesus talked about salvation as being born again.

As Jesus has that conversation with Nicodemus in John chapter 3, what does it mean to be rightly related to God? How do we get there? And Jesus is saying, you can’t get there. You can’t get there unless you’re actually born anew, born again.

And so here, Paul is using a similar language. He’s talking about the birth, the spiritual birth of Onesimus. The spiritual birth of Onesimus is Paul shared the truth of Jesus Christ with him, and Onesimus puts his trust in the Lord Jesus, and he becomes something more than he was before. His identity changes.

In the Lord

And one of the ways that we see that in this passage is when you come to faith in Christ, you are actually placed in Christ, identified with Christ, with God. God identifies you with the very person of Christ over and over again. You see that in various ways, but in particular, the Apostle Paul uses that language when he talks about us being in Christ. He uses that phrase over and over and over again, in Christ.

Do you know what? Your identity, that shapes who we are with God. That shapes who Onesimus is with God. Look down at verse 16. When Paul writes, he says, you’re going to receive him back. How?

A beloved brother.

A beloved brother in the Lord. You see those last closing verses? Those three words, in the Lord? That’s where Onesimus is now. Onesimus is in the Lord. He is identified with the very person of Jesus Christ.

Our identity is in him. It’s not in what people think about us. It’s not in our past actions. If you’ve come to Christ, who you are is defined by who we are in the person of Christ. We’re identified with him.

A New Creature

It is when Onesimus came to faith in Christ, the Holy Spirit entered his heart. He was regenerated, given new life. All these things took place in that moment. He became a new creature in Jesus Christ.

Therefore, if anyone is in Christ, he’s a new creature.

That’s the way it reads in my Bible. Your Bible might say new creation. I was using that verse many years ago, and one of the members of our church came up to me and said, “I really don’t like you to use that phrase, creature. I don’t like to think of myself as a creature.” I think probably you’d seen too many of those B movies in the drive-in about the creatures from the lagoon and so forth.

But anyway, creature simply means created. That’s what it means. A living creation of God. That’s what creature means.

And before Onesimus came to faith in Christ, he was a creature of God. Every one of us born in this world is born as a creature of God. That is to say that we are the result of God’s creative work. We’re here because God created this world, and ultimately, in that process, he created us. We are creatures of God.

Onesimus was a creature of God when he was a slave to Philemon. He was a creature of God, but he was a failed creature of God. He was a creature of God bound in all of his sins. He’s a creature of God that has fallen, just like all people born in this world are creatures who are subject to the sins that we are born with, even from Adam and Eve.

And so we have this propensity in our heart. That’s why we need a new birth. That’s why it was necessary for Onesimus to become a new creature in Jesus Christ. If anyone is in Christ, Onesimus is in the Lord. He’s in Christ.

If anyone is in Christ, then he’s a new creature. Old things passed away. Behold, new things have come.

That’s the story of Onesimus. That’s what we want to be thinking about this morning. Our identity in Christ shapes who we really are, and it’s not what people might think of us. It’s not our past actions, good or bad.

When Onesimus came to Christ, it was what we sang about a few moments ago. All his sins were washed away. We sang that beautiful Cowper hymn that we sang a few moments ago about how, because of the fount that we come to, the fountain, Jesus Christ, we are washed. The sins, the darknesses of our life is washed away by the blood of Christ. And so the things that Onesimus ultimately must fear has been washed away because of his relationship with Jesus Christ.

From a Slave to Sin to a Child of God

So that’s the first point. The second point is that Onesimus’ relationship with God has radically changed from being a slave to sin to being a child of God.

Enslaved to His Own Sins

Onesimus was a slave. Onesimus was a bond slave to Philemon. But that’s not the most significant part of his slavery. The real slavery that Onesimus had was that he was enslaved to his own sins.

I came across a quote by Augustine, who said, and this is in his book about the two cities, Augustine writes,

Thus a good man, though a slave…

If you’re someone like Onesimus, who’s actually a physical slave in this world,

a good man, though a slave, is free.

He’s saying that you can be a slave, bound by all the stuff of slavery, and still be really, truly free. And then he says,

but a wicked man, though a king, is a slave, for he serves not one man alone, but, what’s worse, as many masters as he has vices.

Think about Onesimus here as a slave, entering into true freedom in Jesus Christ. And then think about Nero, who from all outward appearances is able to do anything that he wants, because he has the power to do it. And yet Nero, no one is more enslaved than Nero to all of his vices. You read about his life, what a horrific life. So, a slave.

The Slave and the Son

I want us to look at a passage in John chapter 8, because it’s crucially important. And it’s important how we think about Onesimus. It’s important how we think about ourselves. And in this passage, I’m going to begin in verse 31, I think.

Actually, Jesus is talking, and as he is talking, some people actually enter into true faith. They believe in him. Others believe him. You can’t really tell the difference between those who say they believe him and those who are actually true believers in him. And so Jesus addresses this group, to those Jews who had believed him. And he says,

If you continue in my word, then you’re truly disciples of mine.

Now, a number of them took offense at that. He goes on to say,

If you continue in my word, then you are truly disciples of mine; and you will know the truth, and the truth will make you free.

And when he said that, some of them became angry. They thought that was ridiculous, what he said. He says,

We are the children of Abraham. We’ve never been slaves.

And Jesus makes a pretty powerful point here. He says,

Truly I say to you, everyone who commits sin is the slave of sin.

And then look at what’s next.

The slave does not remain in the house forever; the son does remain forever.

He’s making a distinction. Think about Onesimus and Philemon’s household. Onesimus the slave. Onesimus shared in all sorts of things in the household.

I expect Philemon treated his slaves with great care and dignity. I don’t doubt that at all. In some ways he was like a member of the family.

But he didn’t have a permanent place in the family. A slave has no permanent place in the family. A son belongs to it forever. A slave has no inherent rights, no permanent security. There is no inheritance for the slave. But a son enjoys all these things.

That’s exactly what happened to Onesimus. Before Christ, he’s a slave to sin. But Jesus sets him free. Onesimus became free indeed. He moved from being a slave with no permanent place to a son of God.

Paul basically is saying that he’s my son in the faith. He has a permanent place in the family of God. Onesimus, the slave to sin, is changed, and he becomes the son, the child of God. And that changes everything. Changes everything.

From Useless to Invaluable

The next thing is he moves from useless to invaluable. Christ’s grace transforms our worthlessness into a life of significant value and purpose. Look at verse 11.

Who formerly was useless to you, but now is useful both to you and me.

A Play on Words

And this is the famous play on words that Paul uses in this book. The word Onesimus is a name that means something like useful or beneficial. Here’s a useful person. It was a slave name, and his very name meant he’s useful.

But that wasn’t Philemon’s experience with Onesimus. Actually, he wasn’t something that was beneficial to Philemon. He was someone who cost him dearly. He was someone who proved himself to be unreliable. He was someone who ran away from his responsibilities. He’s not somebody who is useful or valuable at all.

And so Paul says, this man whose name is useful,

formerly was useless to you, but now is useful both to you and to me.

Yeah, that’s what God does. He takes the person who was formerly worthless and of no significant value or purpose, and he gives them tremendous value in Christ Jesus.

A Life Apart From Christ

In the last 20 years, suicides among young people have risen 62%. The leading cause of death among high school students is suicide. They feel worthless.

Even the focus of their education in the secular school is that life itself is meaningless. Nobody might stand up and say life is meaningless, but they teach them with all the things that they teach that it must be. Secular schools are atheistic in what they teach. They’re at best agnostic.

They teach that nobody can know anything for sure, and we live our lives, we look at this universe as if it’s a cosmic accident. And they’re taught that. They’re taught that we are here by accident. So no matter what you do in this world, it’s not going to make any lasting change, because not even this world itself will last. So what’s the point of it?

And that’s what these children are fed. That’s what everybody in our culture is being fed. And they feel like life is hopeless. It’s pointless. That they’re worthless. They have no point.

And you know what? In a real sense, they are worthless, in a real sense.

You know, that’s what we tend to do. You’ve got a child that comes to you who feels hopeless and worthless. They go to the school counselor. What does the school counselor say? “Oh, no, you have a terrible self-image. And we’ve got to work on your self-image,” and pump them up so they feel very entitled and worthless.

They not only feel worthless, but they feel like they’re being cheated, because they’re really worthwhile, but they’re not getting what they’re worth. That’s not the right answer.

You know what the truth is? If they live their life the way they are living it, it will be a worthless life. It will be of no value. This world, living in this world apart from Jesus Christ, is a hellish experience. And it leads to hell. And it leads to no good.

And people live their lives empty and worthless. They may accomplish all kinds of things in this world, build all sorts of technologies and wonderful things that people take pride in, but it is empty and it’s worthless if they’re not related to Jesus Christ. It’s pointless.

Precious to God

You have to come to terms with who you are first before you can come to Christ. But when you come to Christ, that radically changes. It changes in every way. Life is pointless apart from Jesus Christ, but with Christ, it is so precious.

The wonderful hope of the gospel is that we can change. It changes us. It’s the same answer that transformed Onesimus from being a useless runaway slave into an invaluable beloved brother in Christ, someone that will be there forever. New birth in Christ doesn’t just change our eternal destination. It changes our very worth here and now, giving us purpose and meaning in the kingdom of God.

God himself values his children. I started this morning with, we may be few, but we’re precious. If you are a child of God here, God holds you to be precious. And not because of the stuff you’ve done in your life. In spite of those things, he sees you in the beloved Son himself, in the Beloved. He sees you in Jesus Christ.

And he loves Christ vitally. And so he’s at work in your heart, changing you, perfecting you, moving you from sinfulness and making you into the valuable person who will be with him forever and ever.

So when we come to Christ, our identity isn’t wrapped up in what we’ve done or what other people think of us. Our identity is Christ himself.

Our life is hid with Christ in God,

and our value is based on what Christ has done for us: washing away our sins, perfecting us. All Christ’s righteousness is given over to us in the sight of God.

Restoring Broken Relationships

So third, Christ’s transformative work moves us towards reconciliation, empowering us to restore broken relationships. Verses 12 to 14.

I’ve sent him back to you in person, that is, sending my heart, whom I wish to keep with me, so that on your behalf he might minister to me in my imprisonment for the gospel; but without your consent I didn’t want to do anything, so that your goodness would not be, in effect, by compulsion but of your own free will.

Onesimus’ relationships have changed, beginning with his relationship with God. Before he was a slave to sin, now he’s a child of God. His relationship with the Apostle Paul has changed. He didn’t know Paul probably before, but now Paul loves him like a son. That’s very clear in this passage. He calls him his very heart.

And it’s necessary for Paul to send Onesimus back to Philemon, because it’s important that this broken relationship with Philemon changes well. And so Paul points out to Philemon that he would like to have kept Onesimus with him as a gift from Philemon, in order to serve him for the sake of the gospel and his imprisonment, because Onesimus was a blessing to Paul.

But he didn’t want to do anything. He didn’t want to coerce Philemon in any way. If Philemon decides to give Onesimus to Paul, his service to Paul in that way, then it needs to be not by compulsion. It needs to be a free action, exercising his freedom in Christ to do something pleasing to God.

So that’s that section. Onesimus’ relationships have changed, and it’s necessary for this broken relationship with Philemon to be fixed.

The Providence of God Redeems the Past

So fourth and the last point is that through the providence of God, a transformation in Christ redeems past broken relationships and establishes a blessed and eternal relationship. Verses 15 and 16.

For perhaps he was for this reason separated from you for a while, that you would have him back forever, no longer as a slave, but more than a slave, a beloved brother, especially to me, but how much more to you, both in flesh and in the Lord.

The Providential Hand of God

Paul’s calling attention first of all to the providential hand of God at work. He’s calling attention to that moment when Onesimus, doing whatever it was that he did, and we don’t know what he did. We know it was no doubt costly to Philemon in some way.

We don’t know if Onesimus was entrusted with some valuable things and he embezzled those things, stole from Philemon, or maybe all he did was fail in this effort, so that he was the servant who, not taking good care of his responsibility, created a loss and then didn’t want to face up to it. Either way, it was costly to Philemon.

But when that took place, and when Onesimus ran away, and Philemon experienced all this sorrow, Paul is saying, you know what? It’s the providence of God. God’s hand is in this for good, and we can see it.

He’s saying, Onesimus has experienced this wonderful transformation. Would that have happened? Onesimus has come to faith in Jesus Christ and has moved from being a slave to sin to being a son of God.

And you’re getting something back that is far more precious than a slave who will serve you in this life. He might have done you all kinds of good in this life, but that would have been the end of it. Now you have a brother forever, a brother for all of eternity.

Friends for Eternity

And when you look around at you, at each other, as we think about us, do you see each other as friends for eternity? Do we think of the eternal when we look at each other and understand the true value that we have with each other? We are truly precious.

We should be precious to each other because we are precious to God, and we will exist forever in heaven. What great gifts. What an incredible gift God has given me to have you as my eternal friends. That’s a precious gift.

And Paul is saying, Philemon, I’m giving Onesimus back to you, not merely as a slave. I’m giving him back to you as a precious eternal gift forever and ever. It’s an incredible thing. What an incredible thing salvation does.

So the providential hands that God has at work, working good, sovereignty over all things, includes those past disappointments and sorrows. But he uses that in the life of a believer to shape them to be more like Christ himself. It ultimately works to their good. So that’s the experience of Philemon, and that’s the experience of Onesimus.

Shattering the Mirror

Now, as we close our time in Philemon this morning, we’ve walked alongside Onesimus on this journey. We’ve seen how through Christ his reality was redefined.

  • He moved from being a slave to sin to becoming a new creature in Jesus Christ, a child of God.
  • He was transformed from being a person who was useless and worthless to becoming invaluable, a person of eternal worth and eternal purpose.
  • A radical interchange compelled him and compelled the Apostle Paul to bring about reconciliation and restore that broken relationship with Philemon.
  • And ultimately, we saw that God’s own hand of providence was at work to take that painful situation that had happened years before and establish a beautiful, blessed, and eternally blessed relationship that was rooted in Jesus Christ.

Remember, at the beginning we talked about the looking glass self, and how much of our identity is shaped by what others reflect back to us, or our own actions or failures or social labels. Onesimus, trapped in that looking glass self: a runaway, a thief, a liability, a piece of property, the world’s mirrors showing him that his brokenness and his worthlessness, his past.

But the story of Onesimus is the power of the gospel to shatter that mirror. And that’s what God does when we come to him. When we come to Christ, our true identity, our deepest value, our eternal purpose, our relationships is not what we’ve done in the past. Those are washed away by the blood of Christ. Or what others think about us, or what our circumstances are.

Our eternal value is based on Christ and what Christ has done for us. And that’s who we are. That shapes who we are.

Not a Slave but a Saint

Onesimus has become a saint. And Philemon previously had refreshed the hearts of the saints. And now Paul sends Onesimus back not as a slave, but as a saint, one who’s been separated to God for his use. That’s what happens to you when you’re saved. You’re separated to God for God’s own use.

We need to remember that. We shouldn’t let the cracked mirrors of this world define what we look like. It’s going to do a pretty miserable job.

We need to recognize that in Jesus Christ, we are invaluable, not because of who we are in ourselves, but who Jesus Christ makes us to be by his blood and work for us. And we need to trust him. And we need to look humbly to him. We need to look for the transformative work of Jesus Christ in our life. Let’s pray.

Father, we thank you for the preciousness of your holy word. We thank you for the grace that you’ve given us in Jesus Christ to change us. Thank you for the fact that you have moved us out of death into life. You’ve moved us out of darkness into your kingdom of light. You have changed our very heart.

You have sanctified us, placing us in the person of Christ, and you continue to sanctify us, removing sin from our life. We thank you that our identity is shaped by Jesus Christ, that our very life is hid with Christ in God. We thank you, Father, for gifts unimaginable that you have given us, way beyond anything we could express.

And we thank you, Father, that because of this, not because of any merit of our own, but because of the work of Christ, we have eternal worth. And you love us with a mighty love.

We don’t deserve any of it. Onesimus didn’t. Paul didn’t. Philemon didn’t. We certainly don’t. But out of your grace and mercy you’ve given it, and we’ve received it.

Thank you, Father, for all you’ve done for us. Bless us, we pray, in the name of our Savior, the Lord Jesus. Let us live a life that’s worthy of such a great salvation. We ask that in Jesus’ name. Amen.

Stay in Touch

Receive Updates

News and upcoming events from Mayflower Hills, sent to your inbox.